Showing posts with label bureaucracy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bureaucracy. Show all posts

Saturday, September 7, 2024

My Role in introducing Rural Postal Life Insurance in India

 My Role in introducing Rural Postal Life Insurance in India


Great and thought-provoking cartoon. I experienced this situation when I was Director Postal Life Insurance at Postal Directorate, New Delhi in 1993-95. I read in a magazine, Business India, about the Malhotra Committee of Reforms in the Insurance Sector. Contacted them and apprised them that the Department of Posts is the second largest player in the insurance field. However, it has been restricted in its activities within the government and PSU sector. They asked me to prepare a paper on it which I did in a day and submitted to higher authorities. Shamsur Rahman Faruqi happened to be the Member in charge. He appreciated it and asked me to send to the Committee. Later he asked me to put it up for the perusal of the then Secretary, S K Parthasarathy. He resented and wrote on the file that in oral evidence, no such matters needed to be discussed. I asked for guidance from Faruqi Sahab who smiled and said go ahead and don't worry. 

I attended the Committee deliberations twice for oral evidence, once along with my immediate boss, B K Mohanty DDG (PLI) and second time alone since he was on tour. On the second occasion, Mr Malhotra literally noted down all the points I made along with the roadmap I had put forward. He reproduced it in para 7 of the Committee report and the said report was out within a fortnight. 

When I heard the announcement in the evening on Doordarshan, I was afraid of what the Secretary might say. The next morning I reached earlier than my usual time and lo, got a call from PS to the Secretary to come down and meet him. With my legs shaking I rushed down the stairs instead of waiting for the lift. As I was ushered in, the Secretary got up from his seat, greeted and congratulated me. He had received a copy of the said report from the Secretary Telecom, who had congratulated him. I was totally surprised.

Anyway, I had worked day and night to get the scheme of RURAL POSTAL LIFE INSURANCE approved, first from the Malhotra Committee of Insurance, then from the Actuary and later from Government authorities. After some time I learnt that the PM wanted to launch the scheme himself on a particular occasion to encash it being a great and popular step and thus we had to wait. Incidentally, the scheme opened a 50,000 crore market (sum assured) for our department. 

Meanwhile, my boss, B K Mohanaty had announced through all Heads of the Circle that he was coming up with a great scheme in Rural PLI. A very cunning and scheming Officer, he wanted to take credit for this achievement himself and in the meantime got me transferred from PLI Directorate to Postal Staff College, Ghaziabad. We had kept the cyclostyled orders ready for issue which bore my signatures waiting for orders from PMO any moment. But that was not to be. It was thus left to my successor to sign the orders. All that was the contribution of my boss, who did not know even the ABC of insurance, was to talk to everyone who mattered in the department to inform them about the scheme and to remove my signatures as if I didn't exist in the scheme of things. Worse still was that Mr Mohanty, gave adverse remarks on my annual confidential report that year. I was, however, saved by the appreciation letter received earlier from Mr S C Mahalik, the then Secretary of the Department and the review of my ACR by the Counter-signing authority, the then Member, P K Bagchi. However, I must confess that such adverse remarks had no effect on me as I had got used to receiving them in the past and continued to receive them in the future as well. I am still not able to comprehend how I managed to rise to the level of Member Postal Services Board (Additional Secretary, Govt of India) before I finally retired in 2010. 

I firmly believe that BUREAUCRACY HAS ITS FUNNY SIDE TOO

Wednesday, October 28, 2020

Agony Of The Soul: English Short Story; Author: Deepak Budki; Translator: Jawahar Lal Bhat

Agony Of The Soul: English Short Story

 Author: Deepak Budki

 Translator: Jawahar Lal Bhat

She was a very senior Indian Audit and Accounts Service Officer. Her name was Shivangi Menon. Those days when she qualified,  very few girls appeared and qualified for the Civil Services Examination. Those who were successful nourished a secret desire to take aggressively compete with fellow officers. Superseding their colleagues and going ahead of them was a profound tendency, a strange fire, and a maddening urge with these young fiery women!!!

She too had nourished the same dreams. Being a single child, she enjoyed both the love of a son and the care of a daughter from her parents. Besides schooling her in a local Convent, her parents readily agreed to whatever she said and pampered her absolutely by fulfilling all her demands and aspirations. Little did they know that by doing so they were sowing the seeds of egoism, conceit and vanity in their daughter.

During probation, she became friendly with an Indian Administrative Service probationer Vikas Sharma, a happy-go-lucky, flamboyant and impassioned young man. A strong lover of music both instrumental and vocal, he also had a sweet tooth for delicious foods.

Soon both of them came very close and were seen moving together along the serpentine roads of Mussorie during late nights trying to discuss and explore future dreams of their life together. On weekends they enjoyed booze and pop music in the Whispering Windows, a restaurant patronized mostly by Westernized young. During moments of such dazedness, Shivangi opened her heart to Vikas in the hope that he would sincerely respect her love, little knowing that he belonged to a family where everything was weighed in terms of money and riches.  He however knew that he was simply passing time with her and continued taking advantage of the openness of Shivangi in the Academy.

After completion of training, both returned to their homes. Vikas, in accordance with the wishes of his parents, proceeded with his wedding procession to the house of the State Finance Minister to marry his only daughter while Shivangi kept waiting and longing for him endlessly.

It was like an earthquake in the life of Shivangi, tremors which she kept feeling continuously all her life. The tremors would have subsided had she got a suitable match but neither she could find anyone better in status compared to her nor even at par with her. Frustrated, she finally decided not to enter into a matrimonial alliance all her life.

Shivangi tried her best to get herself out of this shock but found it difficult. So she got lured to worldly pleasures, chasing money and a hedonistic way of life. Gradually she started reading fiction during her leisure besides indulging in drinking like a fish, listening to Western music and even dancing with scintillating tunes in her solitude. Time still fell heavy on her because neither smoking nor boozing helped.

When hope is lost in life, all elegance, grace, glamour, and desire to show off is finished. One is overcome with a strange sluggish attitude and inertness and the sense of inactivity overpowers. The same happened with Shivangi. She started gaining weight day after day as layers of fat gradually deposited on her body. All interest in life was lost for her and the only thing that remained with her was to see days slip into nights and nights turn into days.

Whatever the circumstances, life had to be lived. Casual friends came in occasionally, passed time with her over cupfuls of wine, and left. She could find none among them who would extend to her a few words of sincere warmth of love not to speak of owning her as a life partner.  She had never imagined that life would take such an unpleasant turn for her.  Meanwhile, she lost the solitary support of her mother who until then had overshadowed her life in its true sense.

One day, while casually talking to the head clerk of her office in whom she reposed faith, she was unable to hide her state of utter desperation in life. In reply, the head clerk alluded to a topic that astonished her to the core. He said, “Madam, I hope you remember a casual worker who worked in this office long ago, Sadanand by name, a very gentle and good-natured man who had a  spiritual aura about him. Taking pity on his condition, he had been put on a casual job by one of your predecessors. He worked for four to five years with sincerity and then disappeared suddenly. After some time the Supreme Court in one of its orders directed the Government to confirm all the casual employees and he was one of them. Consequently, we began to search for him so that he too derives the benefit of the windfall on the casual employees. It soon came to light that he had withdrawn from active life and had become a Sadhu. He had established an Ashram in a remote village which presents a wondrous spectacle. Thousands of people visited him daily to seek his blessings. Through day and night, Bhajans and Kirtans are sung by devotees. People say he has solved the problems of numerous individuals with his spiritual healing touch. Lots of people with serious ailments have been miraculously cured through his blessings. Surprisingly here in this office, everyone took him as a simpleton and unworthy of anything tangible!”

“Such things do happen. Human faces are usually deceptive. Nobody knows what’s hidden inside this frail frame, both good and bad! We all wear shoddy faces while the truth about us is known only to the almighty God. There are many such people who are blessed with strange spiritual powers but they do not display any traces of their exalted status from outside," responded Shivangi quickly.  

From that day onwards Shivangi nourished a strong desire to meet Swami Sadanand, though at the back of her mind was her own official superiority which resulted in some reluctance too. It was a struggle between her emotive behaviour and her reason. 

"How would she go to meet and prostrate herself before a person who was an ordinary casual worker in her office?" she would ask herself. But soon her reason retorted, “He is no longer your employee. He has renounced this world and become an ascetic. He is now an illuminated soul closer to the truth.”

Again her emotive behaviour outpoured its own resentment, “What would people say? Such a senior officer and bowing down before an ordinary worker, a peon of yesterday!”

Her reason came once again to her rescue, “Let people say what they say! Even Lord Rama didn’t escape the taunts of people!”

This fight between head and heart continued for quite some time till one day her reason was the winner and she decided to visit Swami Sadanand.

The next day, dressed in a simple khadi saree she reached Sadanand’s Ashram. She experienced a wonderful feeling of the liberation of spirit and ananda as she took the first step towards freedom from the shackles of life.

How much was she bound by the chains of worldly affairs! Though she was highly educated and intelligent yet she was unable to liberate herself from the ordinary fetters of life. In a life of loneliness and solitude with no one around to take care of her, she often wondered about her life's purpose. She drew a fat salary and owned a decent bungalow where she was scared to live alone. It was in fact the insecurities of her life that had overwhelmed her to the core. It is because of loneliness that she shifted to a small flat and rented out her big house in order to escape the insecurity on one hand and make some money on the other. The rent she paid for the flat was less than half compared to earnings from the house. Whenever she went on official tours she invariably ensured that the bills are paid by her hosts. Like other officers, she too overbilled her expenditures and claimed in her TA bills amounts far above what was expended by her. Sometimes you could see her fighting with the caretakers on petty expenditures.

It was beyond comprehension why she was so much after money and stingy in her spending. For whom was she collecting all her money and who was there to benefit from her huge savings? She could not be called a miser because she lavishly spent on her foreign liquor, expensive Cigarettes and Cigars. In fact, she had become addicted to certain habituations that she could not shed away, so she continued with these things like the sorrow that she had nurtured in her heart!

But now things were shaping up. Her visits to the Ashram of Swami Sadanand became a routine for her. Swami Ji had also come to know about her through common sources, so he extended due respect and compassion to her and stressed upon her to make amends for her current behaviour come what may. He sincerely desired that her life is saved from going inordinately wasteful like that. Shivangi involved herself fervently in the affairs of the Ashram. She made it a routine to be there every Friday evening without fail after office hours and returned home on Sunday evening. She also took a keen interest in the maintenance and upkeep of the Ashram and became its integral part.

Time marched on and years slipped by.  Shivangi attained the age of superannuation and retired from her service. Strange enough, the office presented a deserted look after she was gone which is rarely noticed in offices. Everyone missed her cheerful and carefree attitude, lively conversations full of confidence with her employees, attending farewell parties and extending lots of affection and love to all.

After retirement, she engaged herself almost full-time in the affairs of the Ashram. In spite of this, she did not seem to realize the true purpose of her life. The more stress she lay on her mind to get awakened to the truth of life, the more agony did she experience. Swami Ji tried his best to take her nearer to the realities of existence but the knots she had developed in her mind did not wear away. She continued to be feeling a vacuum inside her and was far from the absolute truth.

After some time she permanently shifted to the Ashram. Occasionally she fell into deep introspection thinking about her past life and her wasted career. In her desperateness, she would sometimes open her briefcase and examine her possessions, papers representing her savings in fidelity bonds and equity shares, bank deposits, and the ownership of immobile properties. She would often laugh looking at them, thinking about her inability to live a successful life and would question herself about the purpose of the riches she had accumulated throughout her life. What was this all? Did she do all this for eating two chapatis, a few helpings of vegetables and a bowlful of Dal? What good was this money for and what has her status ultimately bestowed on her? Just nothing! Everything seemed to be of no use to her now. A soft smile passed like a mild lightening over her lips and vanished as fast as it had come.

Exasperated, one day she called her advocate and told him, “Mr. Narang, I want to make my Will!”

“Okay, madam! Everything will be done as you desire!”

Shivangi opened all her papers before Mr Nararang and asked him, “Can you tell me about the market value of these assets?”

“I am a lawyer, madam, not an assessor. I cannot make a correct assessment of their value, however, I can give you a tentatively estimated value!”

“Okay, tell me what your estimate is? ”

Narang checked the papers one by one, made some rough calculations on his calculator and said after some time, “I guess it is a property worth about a crore!”

“It is okay; now draft for me complete papers of my Will as per law and get it registered in a court of law.”

“In whose name, madam? Who is going to be your heir? ”Narang asked.

“In the name of Swami Sadanand Trust! It has to be mentioned here that in the event of my death, this property shall stand transferred in the name of the said trust. I will pay whatever expenses are incurred on writing and registering the Will. Besides, I want a copy of Will to be sent to Swami Ji as well.”

The advocate looked with amazement at her but noticed a wonderful feeling of peace and contentment on her face. For the first time, Shivangi felt light without any encumbrances and at peace with herself.

That night she had such a peaceful sleep as experienced never before!


*****

Saturday, June 27, 2020

An Interview To Remember; एक यादगार साक्षात्कार; ایک یادگار انٹرویو ; Deepak Budki


   An Interview To Remember;
एक यादगार साक्षात्कार;ایک یادگار انٹرویو 
 Deepak Budki

In 1973 I resigned from my job at Kashmir Govt Arts Emporium (A unit of J&K Handicrafts S&E Corporation) and went to Delhi to look out for a job. I was 23 years old, armed with MSc (Botany) and B Ed degrees from Kashmir University. An interview call had been received from Apeejay Public School, Faridabad. As I entered the room and was seated in front of the interview board, one of the interviewers said, " You are from Kashmir University, isn't it?"
"Yes Sir", was my answer.
"Oh, that University....! It reminds me of a bad experience I had with them. Once they sent me MA (Political Science) answer books for evaluation. After 2 months I received a reminder to send the evaluation sheets and answer books as it was too late. I replied that first you send me the honorarium due to me then only shall I send the result sheets otherwise not. In fact, I learned that they always delay in paying the honorarium and one has to remind them several times before money is received. The correspondence went on for another month or so. Then they informed me that I need not send the result sheets as they have already announced the result on the basis of the average of other subjects. That was enough to shock me."
It looked like I had started on the wrong foot. A very bad picture had been painted by him on the minds of the interview board. So I had not only to prove my mettle but also to remove the negative image from their minds. I humbly replied, "Sir, have you come here to evaluate my university or me. You ask me relevant questions and I shall try to answer."
Other members agreed with me and after that, the expert on Biology asked me several questions which I answered to the best of my ability.
At the end, I asked, "Sir, how did I fare, will I be selected?"
"That we can't tell you now, there are thirteen candidates in your category, you are seventh and six are yet to be interviewed."
"Okay Sir, I shall wait outside till all of them are interviewed because I cannot afford to go to Srinagar and come back if selected that too when no TA/DA is permissible."
"Okay wait outside, we will see," The Chairman said.
After they finished with the other candidates, I again approached them and asked for the result. The Chairman said, "It is not possible to inform you right now unless the result is approved by the Competent Authority."
"But Sir, you have already decided the Competent Authority has simply to endorse it. You should be able to let me know."
"No, no, that is not permitted by the rules."
"Sir, I waited this long only to tell you that all institutions go by Rule Book. Nobody can short-circuit them. Isn't it? My Kashmir University also has laid down certain rules about evaluation and payment to evaluators, and nobody can force them to change the rules. Anyway, I am aware you won't be able to tell me the result now due to bureaucratic red tape. So be it. Anyway, I am going back."
After a few days, I received a postcard for joining the job but I declined with the following reply sent on a postcard.
"My offer was rejected on the spot. Since no TA/DA is given, I can only afford to travel on my own once. Thanks."
Incidentally those days there were no walk-in interviews

My First Interview; मेरा पहला इंटरव्यू; میرا پہلا انٹرویو ; Deepak Budki

My First Interview;मेरा पहला इंटरव्यू;
میرا پہلا انٹرویو  
Deepak Budki

I thought of relating an experience of the maiden interview I had to face in 1971. I completed my MSc (Botany) & B Ed in 1971 at the age of 21. I used to teach the children of the MD of J&K Handicrafts Corporation without any remuneration due to the insistence of my late father who was working in the organization and inching towards retirement. My father was very hardworking and honest but had faced many problems in the office during his short career. He was keen to get an extension due to liabilities at home. The MD too had a reputation of honesty and he was happy with the work of my father.
My father had joined the organization in 1961 after giving up two well-located handicraft shops, one on the Bund & another in the Central Market, on the insistence of my late mother. He was appointed as Manager initially but after some time was told that his appointment was only that of Asstt Manager. Being naive to Bureaucratic bungling, he resented and accepted just ₹200/- pm as pay till his case was settled. Even as Asstt Manager he would otherwise be entitled to ₹250+ pm. The case took more than 10 years to be decided in his favor but no arrears were paid to him. With this meager sum the widower looked after one son and three daughters.
The organization opened its gates to new blood for the first time as the MD invited applications for jobs of Managers/Asstt Managers. MD instructed my father to tell me to apply for the job. I refused straight away explaining that I want to join the Education Department and am qualified for the same. Father talked to my uncle who had a great influence on me, he painstakingly explained to me the situation of the household and convinced me to send my application.
A written examination was held in which I stood 3rd in the list. One Abdul Samad (MA Eco) was placed first and Ms Madan, daughter of the Secretary of the organization was placed second.
Then came the Oral interview in which there were three members, one was the MD himself, another was Mr Tambe, MD JK Industries, and third I didn't find out who he was. Mr Tambe, IAS had earlier worked as Commissioner, forest department for some time. So he shot out questions about plants and vegetation.
"What do you know about the vegetation of the temperate region?" I explained what the characteristics of the temperate region are compared to Tropical and Sub-Tropical regions but simultaneously told him that it is not humanly possible to give the names of all plants in the temperate regions. He realized that and therefore, shot another question, "What is an exotic?" I correctly described what exotic means. He asked me to give an example, possibly had Chinar in mind. I was nervous, couldn't remember any, but since I was working on root ecology of a plant I thought how much botany might this fellow be knowing. So I replied, "Sir, Salvia moorcroftiana." He looked at me bewildered but immediately added, "How about Chinar?" I was not aware of its origin so said confidently, "Oh Sir, Platanus orientalis". He shot another question, "Where did it come from?" I almost got frustrated but held on my nerves, "Sir there are several views about its origin. Some say it is indigenous, some say it came from China ( I thought Chinar word has China in it ), and some say it came from the Middle East." So left no options. MD felt that I was replying well so he told Mr Tambe, "Ask him more if you please." I was on the verge of breaking down. But thank God they told me it is all over, I could go.
The result was announced after some days. A few candidates, even those who were far below me in the merit list, were appointed as Managers (The Secy's daughter declined the offer) while I was offered Asstt Managers post in the pay scale of ₹140-250. The list had its communal markings on it. Was Shocked, so I didn't want to join but again under the pressure of my uncle and father had to join my first posting as Asstt Manager, Kashmir Govt Arts Emporium, Chandigarh on 01 April 1971

Thursday, February 9, 2012

Mid-term Performance-Review of Bureaucrats: (English)

  Mid-term Performance-
Review of Bureaucrats: (English)

In its latest decision the Central Government has decided to retire all such Officers of Indian Civil Services viz IAS, IFS, IPS, IAAS, IRS, IRaS, IPoS, IIS etc who are found inefficient upon review after 15 and 25 years of service. They will however be entitled to pension as earned by them on such date. The exercise is aimed at increasing efficiency in the bureaucracy besides bringing down corruption in the administration.
Previously officers were permitted to seek voluntary retirement with a similar view to weed out the dead wood but the scheme proved counter productive as it was the efficient officers who sought retirement because they got better offers from the private sector companies while dishonest and inefficient officers stayed put.
In order to understand the implications of the present scheme we have to analyse as to how the Indian bureaucracy absorbs and develops new talent and functions in our democratic set up. Traditionally, in our society first preference is given to medicine and engineering degrees for which one has to qualify pre-medical or pre-engineering examinations with very high merit. Whoever are left, try to obtain graduation degrees in various disciplines and some of them appear in Indian Civil Service examination. However in the case of children of  Government Officers who taste perks of bureaucracy early in their life, the career charting is different. Most of them are groomed for the civil services from childhood itself. Consequently, the bureaucracy turns out to be a jugglery of mediocrity who pose as know-alls in all fields, fill positions from District Collectors to Secretaries, go on deputations to Public enterprises and manage PSUs as diverse as Steel giants, textile manufacturers, drug companies and fertiliser corporations. Nevertheless, with liberalisation of economy the scenario has changed and bright people now look towards multinational corporations for better career prospects. On the contrary the civil services have started attracting maladjusted engineers and doctors of late. But then India is a country of 120 crores and therefore despite this change of preference long queues can still be noticed for getting into Indian Civil Services. As already mentioned the children of erstwhile bureaucrats continue to prefer the Services while the Politicians tactically prefer matrimonial alliances of their children with such officers who would help them in the long run. It can be seen that most of these officers come from particular colleges and from specific locations like Delhi, Allahabad etc. The alumni of these colleges help each other in networking, lucrative postings, deputations, foreign assignments and even promotions.
It is no secret that most of the bureaucracy in India is corrupt. A few who are exceptions only prove the rule. One may recall the in-house voting conducted by UP bureaucrats some years ago to find out the most corrupt officers in the cadre. The results were startling. The bureaucracy has inherited corruption from their forerunners in the British establishment but it received a new impetus from the socio-political set up of the country. The politicians and bureaucrats form a vicious circle, one promotes the other. The bureaucrats who help politicians to achieve their nefarious objectives subsequently get party tickets for elections and become ministers after their retirement. Under these circumstances the bureaucrats lose no time to implement illegal orders of their political bosses and fill their coffers both in India and abroad.
With the implementation of the announced scheme, it needs to be noted that evaluation of Officers after completion of 15 or 25 years of service will entirely depend upon the performance appraisals of such officers recorded year after year. Who will write these Annual Confidential Reports (ACRs)? They will either be written by their political bosses if the officers are senior enough or by such superior officers whose bridle will be in the hands of politicians. Both of them will be prejudiced against honest and conscientious officers. Given the fact that honesty is inversely proportional to efficiency in a country like India, this too will work as a handicap against the honest officers while the dishonest and smart officers will have smooth ride throughout their career.
The performance of officers also depends upon the places they work, the environment they are set in and the prevailing work culture. The officers with better network and effective godfathers have no difficulty in getting postings of their choice at places where they do not face any problems whatsoever. They enjoy their postings as also manage excellent ACRs while their counterparts work under adverse conditions and face militants, naxals, labour unions or political hooligans and resultantly are not able to show as good tangible results. I remember the case of an officer who was brought on deputation to Delhi, his home town, from a militancy infested state to become a member of the team set up for organising an international exhibition while his counterpart in the militancy infested state was asked to look after double charge i.e his own job as also the job of the deputationist. The officer on deputation worked in his home town, his children continued to receive education in Delhi's elite school, he expanded his network by including more politicians in it, got an outstanding ACR, received an award and managed his posting to Delhi after the end of the exhibition while the period of exhibition was shown as having worked in  the militancy infested state. The other officer whose life was in danger could only get an average ACR because none of his bosses ever visited the state during the period where they could have appreciated the good work he had done. Such are the ways of bureaucracy!
The most important tool for evaluation of work of officers is through targets assigned to them, both quantitative and qualitative, and achievements against them. While it may be easy to fix targets for the officers in the field, it is not so easy to fix targets for those officers who work in the Ministries and Secretariats and deal with files only without getting exposed to practical difficulties. Even if such targets are fixed arbitrarily they remain only an eye wash and therefore are prone to the subjective evaluation of their bosses. Such officers have a definite edge over the former and therefore secretarial jobs provide a shelter for the blue eyed boys who manage postings in such places.
The proposed system will work against the interests of the officers belonging to reserved categories such as scheduled castes, scheduled tribes, other backward classes and minorities who do not have many godfathers in higher echelons of bureaucracy. Given the fact that they are admitted to Civil Services with lower merit, they are not expected to be as intelligent as their higher caste colleagues and produce similar results. Therefore, their weeding out will be facilitated surreptitiously. Even today if seniority lists are analysed thoroughly it will be noticed that the percentage of officers belonging to these categories dwindles gradually as they go up the ladder in their career and may be negligible at the end of the road due to the subjectivity and prejudice. Many officers of lower castes are stiffled and stunted enroute during their journey towards superannuation. The proposed scheme will further put hurdles in their path of progress.
Last but not the least it may be seen how sincere the government is for ensuring efficiency of the bureaucracy at present. There are innumerable complaints which have not been even acknowledged not to speak of taken up for investigations. The cases whichever taken up for investigations are not completed for number of years wilfully so that the officers quietly superannuate. Wherever cases are investigated the agencies ensure that these remain week with loopholes in evidence so that these fall by wayside during trial. It would be high time to investigate the mortality percentage of cases handled by the investigating and vigilance agencies of the central and state governments to see how efficient these agencies are. Let us hope the government does not make laws that make cure worse than the disease.

Sunday, October 16, 2011

Kashmir: An Open Letter To Prashant Bhushan: (English); Deepak Budki

Kashmir: An Open Letter To Prashant Bhushan:
 (English); Deepak Budki

Dear Shri Bhushan,

At the very outset let me introduce myself. I am neither a rightist nor a leftist, nor even a centrist. I am just one out of one hundred and twenty crores of Indians, and I belong to Kashmir. I am the original inhabitant of Kashmir with history dating back to five thousand years which is older than Judaism, Christianity and Islam. Over a period of last seven centuries I have been reduced to a minuscule minority of not more than five lakh souls due to repeated invasions, proselytizing and persecution. However, I rejoiced the day my country was declared independent in 1947 though I remained in a state of fix because my brothers and sisters in Baramulla were facing genocide and rapine till such time Maharaja of Jammu and Kashmir finally decided to accede to India. From that day onwards I preferred to exist without complaint in a state of continuous deprivation and denial.The only solace for me was that I lived in my own homeland and country.

But your recent statement pained me immensely. I had heard similar things earlier from a few more self styled activists like Arundathi Roy who has taken upon herself the burden of the nation just because she has written a book in English which has won her acclaim.Had she written the same in any other language she would not be known even beyond her street for you know the fate of other writers in India. Incidentally I have written seven books in Urdu till date. Your statement came as a bolt from the blue because I had pinned many a hope upon the Anna team since I regard Anna as the saviour of the  country in modern times.

May I again emphasise that I am the original inhabitant of Kashmir which has a hindu tradition of five thousand years. Not only that, Jammu and Kashmir is not inhabited by only Kashmiri Muslims but by Dogras, Sikhs, Budhists and Christians as well. Even among Kashmiri Muslims there are differnt sects and schisms such as sunnis and shias, gujjars, Kargil and Ladakh muslims who do not see eye to eye with each other. When you talk of Plebiscite as the ultimate resolution of Kashmir problem you seem to ignore these facts.The Plebiscite carries certain obligations on the part of all the parties involved viz India, Pakistan and the State of Jammu and Kashmir. You may be aware of Pakistan having annexed parts of erstwhile J&K State like Gilgit, Skardu, Hunza, Nagar and Baltistan with mainland Pakistan and having ceded a part of the state to China for strategic purposes to encircle India. Whatever was left was assigned the nomenclature of Azad Kashmir by Pakistan which ironically never enjoyed freedom and democracy in the past six decades as opposed to the Jammu and Kashmir State, a part of India, where liberty, equality and freedom of worship is enjoyed by all the citizens. The original idea of plebiscite was that it was required to be undertaken on return of normalcy in in whole of J&K state without any attempt of ethnic cleansing in any part. Is this practicable now when whole of Pakistan occupied Kashmir has been homogenised  by the Pakistan government and no hindu, sikh or budhist can be seen in the entire Pakistan occupied Kashmir so much so they carried out this ethnic cleansing in Kashmir valley across the LOC by sponsoring terrorism in the valley.

I would perhaps still agree with you if I could understand the basis of such an opinion. Kashmiri separatist leaders have been asserting all through that they are muslims and would like to be part of a Muslim State called Pakistan or form a separate state with Islam as the state religion. That would mean that we accept the two nation theory once again in the same manner as we accepted in 1947 by default though our leaders have been continuously denying the same notwithstanding the creation of Islamic state of Pakistan. In the event we accept this secession of part of our country what prevents other inimical forces to gain strength and seek independence for states like Tamil Nadu, Punjab, Nagaland, Assam, Mizoram, Manipur, Arunachal and Sikkim.Would this situation be acceptable to you to witness this country get fragmented into small innumerable states just because we could not administer them properly and that people like you and Roy lived in posh glass houses with security given at our nation's expense.

May I further ask you whether Pakistan would also hold such a plebiscite in Sindh, Bulochistan and NWFP? I have not noticed you or Arundhati Roy taking any steps or doing anything substantial to coerce China to hold plebiscite in Tibet or grant independence to them. What action did you take when Sri Lankan Tamils were massacred and butchered by the Sri Lankan Army  recently? You and Arundhati Roy could at least have gone to Colombo, courted arrest and gone on indefinite fast to stop the army of Sri Lanka to conduct such a heinous massacre. But you would not do that because no body would care for you. More so they would have annhilated you in no time. Here in India you can get recognition and big name by speaking such things and posing as pseudo human rights activists and our mass media would give you maximum coverage because they increase their market share by such methods.

I understand your love for human rights and sympathise with you. May I know how many Kashmiri Pandit refugee camps did you visit after their exodus in 1990. How much financial help did you render to them from your personal wealth. How many Kashmiri Pandit refugees did you lodge in your house till they could find some accommodation on their own? If you have not done any of these it does not behove you to talk of human rights and human suffering.

Needless to remind you that USA and European nations, after realising what wrong they had done to the Jews in the past, atoned for it and re-established them in Israel by creating a separate home land for them notwithstanding the opposition from the middle east countries and the whole Islamic bloc. On the contrary, you are keen that Kashmir should secede from India and the Kashmiri Pandits should be deprived of their home land and not allowed to return as also perish in due course of time. I only wish good sense prevails upon you and people like you because parasites grow only at the expense of other's.

With regards,
Yours sincerely, 
Deepak Budki.


Rishton Ke Maheen Reshe: Ashma Kaul – Deepak Budki

          Rishton Ke Maheen Reshe: Ashma Kaul                            – Deepak Budki A collection of Hindi short stories titled ‘Rishton ...