Justice Delivered: English Short Story
Author: Deepak Budki
Translator: Jawahar Lal Bhat
That day an unusual thing happened. He greeted
and hugged me in the middle of the road and I kept looking at him with great
astonishment. He looked straight into my eyes, then said, “Hearty
Congratulations! You have cleared the Civil Services Examination. This is a
matter of great pride for all of us.” His gestures appeared both affected and
stagy.
Then he turned to his wife who was standing
beside him and told her, “Ah! He had to waste five precious years of his life
in our wretched Corporation. I was, however, sure he will make it one day and
become a gazetted officer in the Government. See my prophecy has come true!”
He again looked at me with hope and expectation
and after a few moments invited me for a cup of tea at the Grand Hotel which
was nearby.
My astonishment doubled. For five years we had
worked together in the same office. Several times I had visited his office
chamber for some work but he never talked so warmly nor did he call for a cup
of tea. He always put up a long face as if he was facing the worst times of his
life. Seeing him now, I started thinking, "What has befallen this man that
he is showering so much affection on me today? Maybe he is trying to
impress his wife with his high-ranking friend circle, or.... maybe he is
looking for a match in me for a girl of his near relation. These little things
do in fact turn one to behave erratically.
While having tea we talked about many subjects,
the Corporation, state politics, our
personal lives, and many other things. Meanwhile, his wife stole some glances at
me and smiled occasionally. Her smile seemed to enhance the sweetness of the
tea. She was a buxom woman in her naughty thirties.
A few days passed. One day Jagannath accompanied
by his wife arrived at my office and both took seats across the table in front
of me. Immediately after he comforted himself he came out with the purpose of
his visit saying, “We have come to you for some favour.”
“What can I do for you, please let me know.”
“My brother-in-law, Harji Lal works in your
department and is presently on frontier posting in Gurez. His tenure will be over within a month and
his transfer orders are expected anytime.”
“That’s good. Where do you want him to be posted?
Near his home, I suppose?”
“That’s the tragedy, brother! He is an eccentric
person. Has made a hell of our life.” His wife spoke in between.
“He has illicit relations with his elder
brother’s wife and prefers her company
oftentimes. Unbelievable and Strange, isn't it?
But that is what it is. He has brought disgrace to the whole family. He
has distanced himself from his wife, often sends her to the parental house while he
himself enjoys with his sister-in-law.”
“That’s very loathsome!” I said looking into his
piercing feline eyes.
“I want that Harji Lal is posted far away from
this city. Two years ago he managed to get his divorce order from the
subordinate court and has applied for the custody of his child now. Imagine a
mother being denied proximity of her child whose pain she has borne for nine
months.”
“Usually the custody of the child is given to his
mother, the father cannot be awarded his or her custody. That is natural justice.”
“He has deposed in the court through his lawyer
that his ex-wife has no means of income and hence she will not be able to
provide for and care for the child. Moreover, the child is no longer dependent
on his mother’s milk. It looks like he has greased the palm of the Judge
to get a decision in his favour. We do not want his posting anywhere in this city
so he may not be able to attend hearings in the case regularly. The case
will thus get prolonged and maybe by the time the child will attain maturity
and state his own choice in the court.”
“That is a better solution. I understand your
problem. I’ll post him at a place wherefrom he will have to travel a great
distance that will take him a day or two to reach Srinagar.”
Both of them left for their home fully satisfied.
Afterwards, it occurred to me, "Won't it be irrational to form an opinion on
the basis of what I was told by these people? It is just one side of the story. Their assertions may be
tailored to suit their own vested interests and not based on truth. Believing them
and deciding the fate of my subordinate on their half-truths may mean a miscarriage of justice. I must hear the other side too."
My doubts were reasonable, so I decided to
consult some senior officials and union leaders who may be knowing Harji Lal
personally. It would be possible to extract the truth from them or at least get
corroborated the assertions made by the couple. I was able to gather some
tidbits of information and piece them together. One Union leader, a well-learned Hindu, lay the entire blame at the door of Harji Lal. I could feel that
he had a soft corner for women folk as is usual in such matters because Hindus
expect a cent per cent fidelity of men towards their spouses. Later in the day, I
met a Muslim Union leader who knew Harji Lal so well that he burst out with emotions, "You Hindus are all the
same. You want the men to be like galley slaves. No escape even if the wife is
a witch." He gave me some important clues about the case like how the
in-laws of Harji Lal have constantly hounded him, how they had been influencing
my predecessors for keeping him out of this city and how he has been
suffering from gastric ulcers in far-flung areas. I was moved and almost tearful. I sent an unofficial message
through him to Harji Lal asking him to meet me at my residence during the coming holidays.
After about fifteen days there were a few
consecutive holidays including the weekend. On the last day of the holidays
which was a Sunday, I was all alone in my house. My wife had gone to her
parent’s house along with the children. Early in the morning, somebody pressed the
call bell at the outer gate. I was still lying in my bed. I thought it may
either be a newspaper hawker or milkman seeking payment of their monthly bills.
So I hurriedly put on my tweed Pheran (a smock-like apparel worn by Kashmiris) and
opened the gate. Harji Lal stood before me.
I took him to the large room on the ground floor
which we used for receiving and
entertaining guests. You may call it a drawing room though it never looked like
one. Devoid of any furniture, the floor of the room was furnished all over with
locally woven straw mats commonly known as 'Patej' which were covered by pressed
cotton felt rugs called ‘Namdahs’ in local parlance. A few long barrel-shaped
bolsters and pillows lined up against one wall to recline on while sitting. In
an average Kashmiri house, there is generally no tradition of sitting in chairs
and sofas though the rooms are spacious. The guests are received in a large
room called Baithak and all sit on the floor with thick warm flooring to stop
the cold coming from underneath and recline against large long bolsters and
pillows for comfort.
“I’ve come to meet the Sahab Bahadur, he has
called me for a meeting,” Harji Lal informed me. He was at a loss guessing
where he had landed up as he could not find any semblance of a house of an IPS
Officer. He was not able to place me as well as he could hardly expect his
Sahab Bahadur to be in a pheran.
“You are Harji Lal? It is I who called you.
Sit here, I have to talk about something special with you.”
“Is it you, Sir? I am sorry I couldn’t recognize
you. I have never seen you before. I am extremely sorry, Sir. Hope you will
pardon me.”
“No reason for asking pardon. Make yourself
comfortable.” By the time I too sat informally by his side on the floor.
“I have called you here to gather some
information about your personal life if you wish to share. I have heard your
in-laws' side of the story and now I
would like to hear it from you. If you like to throw some light on your
relationship with your wife and recount your personal hardships, it can facilitate me to reach a proper and just
conclusion. I don’t want to make a decision based on what has been stated by
one side only.”
He was totally astonished to find me as his boss
besides being overawed by the environment around him. However, on the other hand,
it helped us to bridge the gap of strangeness immediately and develop
familiarity among ourselves. He was able to shun his shyness and inertia in
communication. Harji Lal had thought he was going to meet an IPS Officer, he would
have to wait for God knows how much time to get an audience and then face many
strange questions but the situation that he faced here was quite different and
encouraging for him. He never expected such informality from a person who had
power in his hands and who had the authority to do or undo things in his
favour.
I tried to comfort him further with some more
assuring words to make him feel that I was his well-wisher and not in any way harmful to his interests so that he could satisfactorily have full trust in me.
He once again looked around to feel reassured and
then spoke, “Sir, the truth of the matter is that I lost my parents in my
childhood. My brother and his wife treated me as their own son and never gave
me an occasion to feel that I was an orphan. After completing my education my
sister-in-law diligently arranged for my wedding and with a lot of hope brought
my wife into the house. Before I could settle down with my marital affairs I
found that my wife was made up of completely different stuff. She could not
reconcile with my brother and sister-in-law in any manner. From the very first
day in my house, she converted it into a battlefield and started fighting with
my brother's wife. She quarrelled with her on all petty issues so fiercely that
our neighbours had to often intervene. She never appreciated the fact that my
brother and sister-in-law have been no less than father and mother to me and it
was only because of them that I was able to stand on my feet. I soon came to
realize that her only aim was to get me separated from them and snap all
relations with my brother and his family.”
“I don’t think there was anything wrong about it
because most of women nowadays prefer to be independent and want to live
their own life without anybody's interference,” I interjected cutting short his
talk in the middle.
“You are right, Sir, but one has to give due
respect to those who deserve it and have substantial consideration for
traditions in the family. She cannot simply lash out and abuse those who have
sustained me all my life and I have treated them as my parents. She stooped so low as
to accuse me of having illicit relations with my mother-like sister-in-law. That was the
height of things and quite unbearable to me as one whom I worshipped as my mother
should be blamed as such.”
“Harji Lal! The circumstances you are in and what
you describe can easily prove you guilty irrespective of whatever the facts may be.” I took to somewhat harder stance to eke out some more critical
information. “You continued to be carefree about your duly wedded wife and
lived with your brother and sister-in-law. Your wife had to often go to her
parental home, you neither stopped her from going nor ever went there to bring
her back. On the contrary, you lived comfortably with your sister-in-law. She
always took care of you. What inference can one draw from this account of yours
on a rational basis?”
“Sir, you are looking only at one side of the
matter. No man would like his wife to stay at her parents and himself to waste
his youth alone in his room. Notwithstanding no sane person would like to live
with such a venomous serpent in the guise of a woman. As regards my living
with my brother may I know where else do I go? This is our parental home and
both I and my brother are equal shareholders. My sister-in-law treats me like
her own son and feeds me as she feeds her own children. They have been looking
after me since my early childhood and will continue to do so in the future. She
often cries bitterly looking at my condition and blames herself for it, saying,
"It was because of me that you had to suffer that hag." Suppose I
part with my brother but tell me, Sir, how can I trust a woman who may ditch me
any time in future without rhyme or
reason?”
“You are right but sometimes one has to
compromise and accept such undesirable circumstances.”
“Compromises are done only when there are faults
on the part of both partners and each one shows a willingness to amend his or her
conduct in the future. Here the situation is miserable. I am a victim of the worst
exploitation and cruelty. The last few years have been pathetic for me. My health
conditions have deteriorated considerably because of the mental stress that I
experienced. Gastric ulcers have formed due to excessive acid formation in my
stomach. I had to undergo major surgery in the hospital a few years back.”
Harji Lal suddenly lifted his shirt off his front body to show me more than a
foot-long scar on his abdomen due to the operation. “Sir, I was in the hospital
for one month and it was only due to the care of my brother and sister-in-law
that I survived otherwise I would have died since. My wife never tried to see
me in the hospital even once.”
“Don’t say that. God always makes an
alternative arrangement for every creature to survive. Incidentally, was your
divorce approved by the court at that time? ”
“No Sir, I was hoping that she will realize her
mistake and return. We have a son as well. It is in fact only this hope that
kept me going on. I thought my own blood will become animated someday and look
out for his father and also force his mother to return to her husband but she
poisoned his ears so bitterly that such a thought never occurred to him while
on the contrary he also turned against me. It was only after this disclosure
that I decided to apply for divorce.”
“I understand, such circumstances are gradually
shaped like that.”
“Sir, I want to tell you a secret that I’ve been
holding close to my chest for many years. I have not revealed it to anyone not
even to the court.” He once again moved his eyes around the room lest someone
else might be spying on their talks or ears might have grown in the walls of the
room and maybe listening to what he was saying. After gaining confidence, he
continued, “I have not divulged this secret to anybody so far but want to
disclose it before you as I have developed a strange familiarity and closeness
with you, Sir.”
“You can say everything without fear. I’ll
closely guard your secret.”
“Sir, if you do not mind, sometimes just walk
down your lane between 3 to 5 pm and as you hit the road you can see a
Chemist's shop ‘New Global Medicate’ on the opposite side across the road.
There you’ll see a lady sitting behind the counter every day. She is my Ex-wife.
She and the owner of the shop are in love with each other since premarital
days. Those days the owner of the shop was just a helper in some other chemist
shop earning a meagre sum and therefore not financially sound. Hence her
parents didn’t consent to their marriage and in order to avoid any untoward
happening they quickly sought out another groom for her. And the axe,
unfortunately, fell on my head. She continued meeting her paramour even after
our marriage. It was rather this relationship that made a hell of my life. She was
very eager to separate from my brother's household so that there is no vigil on
her movements and her paramour can even visit her house in my absence. As they
say, the offence is the best part of the defence. In order to hide her illicit
relationship she made counter false allegations against me and my sister-in-law. She
often made allegations about my character and advertised it widely to malign me.
“Okay, I understand. You can leave now. Give me
some time to reach a decision.”
The next day I returned from my office somewhat
early. I changed my dress, wore ordinary clothes and ordinary slippers, and
walked across the lane to reach the road from where I could see the ‘New Global
Medicate’. I wanted to confirm what Harji Lal had said. After entering
the shop I saw a middle-aged man,
roughly 35 to 40 years old, sitting behind the counter writing something
probably making entries in his daily account. On his right side was seated a
short-statured chubby and fidgety woman with glossy eyes wearing a violet
saree. They were talking unreservedly to each other. She would off and burst
into peals of laughter after lively banter. On looking at her closely I found
her just a carbon copy of the wife of Jagannath who had met me twice. On seeing
me both of them got startled initially but later overcame their apprehension as they did not find me interested in
their personal affairs. I took out a piece of paper from my pocket,
read out the names of some medicines and asked about their availability.
The owner of the store looked at me from head to
foot with amusement and then walked around in search of medicines. He opened a
few almirahs to bring out the cartons containing the medicines, pulled out the
required quantity and placed it on the ledge of the counter. Meanwhile, I kept
watching the gestures of his lady friend looking sideways at her without making
her conscious that I was interested in her. Later on, I visited the store a few
times more after a gap of some days in between the visits and at the specified
time. I would ask for some different medicines every time. During such visits, I
found both of them in the same frolicsome mood as I had seen on day one. The
owner gradually became quite informal with me. Meanwhile, if a customer entered, he would immediately attend to him
and after satisfying him return to his seat. Over a period of time, more and
more facts about them were revealed to me.
Whatever Harji Lal had stated about his ex-wife
proved to be cent per cent correct. I was also fully convinced that this woman
had levelled false allegations against her husband in order to hide her own evil
deeds.
In a week’s time, I acted as was most desired in
this case but beyond the expectations of many. Harji Lal was posted precisely
at the office as was requested by him in his application. How Jagannath and his
wife must have reacted to the order remains unknown to me. I neither tried to
know about it nor did they ever meet me after that. Harji Lal did once come to
meet me in my office and thanked me profoundly.
It was during those days that I was sent on
deputation to Army Postal Service. I was trained in Kampti near Nagpur in
Maharashtra for about two months and thereafter posted to Bareilly, Uttar
Pradesh for the first time. After around six months I came to my home on leave.
In my heart of hearts, I was very eager to know what had become of Harji Lal, so
I went to the post office where I had posted him. He was fortunately available
in the same office where I had posted him though I had apprehended that his
in-laws might have manipulated again to get him ousted from there and got him
thrown far away from the city. On seeing me he immediately left his counter and
fell on my feet.
With tears rolling down his cheeks yet inner
happiness apparent on his face, he said, “Sir, when did you come?”
“I have come just a couple of days back,” I replied.
“Sir, I have got my son back. The court decided
the case in my favour. My in-laws had been trying for a long time to keep me
away from this city such that I would not be able to follow my case in the
court but you were sent by God as a Messiah for me. Your order solved all my
problems. You have reestablished my deserted life, Sir. How can I repay your
favours? Now my son has become quite familiar with me and goes to school
regularly. I am happy as happiness could be, thanks all to your mercy, Sir.”
Rivers were oozing out of his eyes. In spite of
that, he exhibited his inner joy. I cannot say if those tears represented his
joy or his sorrow!!
*****